DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1041.2017.01322

Acta Psychologica Sinica (心理学报) 2017/49:10 PP.1322-1333

The effects of moral punishment and relationship punishment on junior middle school students' cooperation behaviors in public goods dilemma

Several factors can account for the cooperative behaviors in social dilemmas, which include individual differences, reward and punishment system, task design and so on. People have a strong aversion to being the "sucker" in social dilemma situations so that those who prefer cooperation may be willing to punish free-riding. Researches demonstrated that although punishment could promote people's cooperative behaviors temperately, their cooperation levels would drop down to the baseline when the punishment was removed. In previous studies, material punishment was adopted most frequently, however, social punishment has not been sufficiently investigated. Furthermore, there is no unanimous conclusion towards the issue whether the cooperation of the juveniles has any gender differences. So this study mainly examined the effects of moral punishment and interpersonal punishment on the junior middle school student's cooperative behaviors. Last but not least, social value orientation is a relatively stable individual state and is defined as a tendency of allocation proportion between individual and others. Therefore, we further explored the relationship between social value orientation and student's cooperative behaviors under different types of punishment.
Accordingly, the present study consisted of 2 experiments. The first experiment was organized into a 3×2 factorial design. The first factor was the type of punishment, consisting of 3 levels:moral punishment, interpersonal punishment and no punishment. The second factor was the phase of punishment, consisting of 2 levels:punishment in the first phase and no punishment in the second one. Specifically, participants were randomly assigned to the three types of punishment. For punishment groups, participants were given the two phases of punishment. The second experiment was organized into a 3×2×2 factorial design. The first two factors were the same as experiment 1. The third factor was the type of social value orientation, encompassing 2 levels:prosocial participants and proself participants.
The results are as follows, first, the cooperative level was significantly higher in the moral and interpersonal punishment conditions compared to no punishment condition, and the punishment effect remained when the interpersonal punishment removed. Second, punishment effects were significantly greater in the interpersonal and moral conditions than in the no punishment condition for the female participants, but the male participants just had this effect on the case of the interpersonal conditions. Third, a greater cooperative level observed in the moral and interpersonal punishment conditions across both prosocial participants and proself participants, but only the prosocial participants kept a higher cooperative level when the punishment removed.
These results suggested that the moral and interpersonal punishment could promote the cooperative behaviors of the junior middle school students. In comparison, the interpersonal punishment had a more lasting effect, which was more prominent in the male group. Additionally, relative to the case of proself participants, there was a long-term effect on punishment for prosocial participants.

Key words:moral punishment,interpersonal punishment,public goods dilemma,cooperation,social value orientation

ReleaseDate:2017-11-17 09:47:13

Balliet, D., Li, N. P., Macfarlan, S. J., & van Vugt, M. (2011). Sex differences in cooperation:A meta-analytic review of social dilemmas. Psychological Bulletin, 137, 881-909.

Balliet, D., Mulder, L. B., & van Lange, P. A. M. (2011). Reward, punishment, and cooperation:A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 137, 594-615.

Belli, S. R., Rogers, R. D., & Lau, J. Y. F. (2012). Adult and adolescent social reciprocity:Experimental data from the Trust Game. Journal of Adolescence, 35, 1341-1349.

Bogaert, S., Boone, C., & Declerck, C. (2008). Social value orientation and cooperation in social dilemmas:A review and conceptual model. British Journal of Social Psychology, 47, 453-480.

Brucks, W. M., & van Lange, P. A. M. (2007). When prosocials act like proselfs in a commons dilemma. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 33, 750-758.

Bruins, J. J., Liebrand, W. B. G., & Wilke, H. A. M. (1989). About the saliency of fear and greed in social dilemmas. European Journal of Social Psychology, 19, 155-161.

Carlsmith, K. M. (2006). The roles of retribution and utility in determining punishment. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 42, 437-451.

Carlsmith, K. M., Darley, J. M., & Robinson, P. H. (2002). Why do we punish?:Deterrence and just deserts as motives for punishment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83, 284-299.

Chen, S. J., He, Q., & Ma, J. H. (2015). The influence of third-party punishment on cooperation:An explanation of social norm activation. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 47, 389-405.[陈思静, 何铨, 马剑虹. (2015). 第三方惩罚对合作行为的影响:基于社会规范激活的解释. 心理学报, 47, 389-405.]

Chen, W. Y., Lu, J. M., Liu, L. Q., & Lin, W. Y. (2014). Gender differences of empathy. Advances in Psychological Science, 22, 1423-1434.[陈武英, 卢家楣, 刘连启, 林文毅. (2014). 共情的性别差异. 心理科学进展, 22, 1423-1434.]

Chen, X., Zhao, G. X., & Ye, H. S. (2014). The forms and functions of punishment in public-goods dilemmas. Advances in Psychological Science, 22, 160-170.[陈欣, 赵国祥, 叶浩生. (2014). 公共物品困境中惩罚的形式与作用. 心理科学进展, 22, 160-170.]

Chen, X. P. (2013). Solving social dilemmas:The psychological mechanisms of cooperation induction. Beijing:Peking University Press.[陈晓萍. (2013). 走出社会困境:有效诱导合作的心理机制. 北京:北京大学出版社.]

Chen, X. P., Dang, C. T., & Keng-Highberger, F. (2014). Broadening the motivation to cooperate:Revisiting the role of sanctions in social dilemmas. In P. A. M. van Lange, B. Rockenbach, & T. Yamagishi (Eds.), Reward and punishment in social dilemmas (pp. 115-132). Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Chen, X. P., Pillutla, M. M., & Yao, X. (2009). Unintended consequences of cooperation inducing and maintaining mechanisms in public goods dilemmas:Sanctions and moral appeals. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 12, 241-255.

Chi, L. P., Sun, Q., & Li, F. H. (2013). Impact of interpersonal property on child's trust in the bargaining game. Psychological Research, 6, 31-35.[池丽萍, 苏谦, 李福洪. (2013). 议价博弈中人际属性对儿童信任的影响. 心理研究, 6, 31-35.]

Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Gibbs, J., Lieberman, M., Fischer, K., & Saltzstein, H. D. (1983). A longitudinal study of moral judgment. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 48, 1-124.

Coltrane, S., & Adams, M. (2008). Gender and families (Vol. 5, 2nd ed.). Lanham, MD:Rowman & Littlefield.

Croson, R., & Gneezy, U. (2009). Gender differences in preferences. Journal of Economic Literature, 47, 448-474.

De Cremer, D., & van Lange, P. A. M. (2001). Why prosocials exhibit greater cooperation than proselfs:The roles of social responsibility and reciprocity. European Journal of Personality, 15(S1), S5-S18.

Dugar, S. (2010). Nonmonetary sanctions and rewards in an experimental coordination game. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 73, 377-386.

Dush, C. M. K., & Amato, P. R. (2005). Consequences of relationship status and quality for subjective well-being. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 22, 607-627.

Eisenberg, N., Fabes, R. A., Shepard, S. A., Murphy, B. C., Jones, S., & Guthrie, I. K. (1998). Contemporaneous and longitudinal prediction of children's sympathy from dispositional regulation and emotionality. Developmental Psychology, 34, 910-924.

Ewoldsen, D. R., Eno, C. A., Okdie, B. M., Velez, J. A., Guadagno, R. E., & DeCoster, J. (2012). Effect of playing violent video games cooperatively or competitively on subsequent cooperative behavior. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, 15, 277-280.

Fehr, E., & Rockenbach, B. (2003). Detrimental effects of sanctions on human altruism. Nature, 422, 137-140.

Fiedler, S., Glöckner, A., Nicklisch, A., & Dickert, S. (2013). Social Value Orientation and information search in social dilemmas:An eye-tracking analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 120, 272-284.

Fukushima, H., & Hiraki, K. (2006). Perceiving an opponent's loss:Gender-related differences in the medial-frontal negativity. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 1, 149-157.

Furman, W., & Buhrmester, D. (1985). Children's perceptions of the personal relationships in their social networks. Developmental Psychology, 21, 1016-1024.

Gibbs, J. C., Basinger, K. S., Grime, R. L., & Snarney, J. R. (2007). Moral judgment development across cultures:Revisiting Kohlberg's universality claims. Developmental Review, 27, 443-500.

Guala, F. (2012). Reciprocity:Weak or strong? What punishment experiments do (and do not) demonstrate. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 35, 1-15.

Haidt, J. (2003). The moral emotions. In R. J. Davidson, K. R. Scherer, & H. H. Goldsmith (Eds.), Handbook of affective sciences (pp. 852-870). Oxford:Oxford University Press.

Harter, S. (1999). The construction of the self:A developmental perspective. New York:Guilford Press.

Hastings, P. D., Rubin, K. H., & DeRose, L. (2005). Links among gender, inhibition, and parental socialization in the development of prosocial behavior. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 51, 467-493.

He, L. Z., Bian, R., & Che, H. S. (2013). The effects of the social value orientation and feedback formats on decision behavior in the dynamic public goods dilemma. Journal of Psychological Science, 36, 446-452.[何力舟, 卞冉, 车宏生. (2013). 社会价值取向和反馈方式对公共物品困境中决策行为的影响. 心理科学, 36, 446-452.]

Houser, D., Xiao, E. T., McCabe, K., & Smith, V. (2008). When punishment fails:Research on sanctions, intentions and non-cooperation. Games and Economic Behavior, 62, 509-532.

Irwin, K., Mulder, L., & Simpson, B. (2014). The detrimental effects of sanctions on intragroup trust:Comparing punishments and rewards. Social Psychology Quarterly, 77, 253-272.

Kiyonari, T., Tanida, S., & Yamagishi, T. (2000). Social exchange and reciprocity:Confusion or a heuristic? Evolution and Human Behavior, 21, 411-427.

Kollock, P. (1998). Social dilemmas:The anatomy of cooperation. Annual Review of Sociology, 24, 183-214.

Kuhlman, D. M., & Marshello, A. F. (1975). Individual differences in game motivation as moderators of preprogrammed strategy effects in prisoner's dilemma. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32, 922-931.

Lam, C. B., Solmeyer, A. R., & McHale, S. M. (2012). Sibling relationships and empathy across the transition to adolescence. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 41, 1657-1670.

Liu, C. J., & Hao, F. (2011). Social value orientation and cooperation in asymmetric social dilemmas. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 43, 432-441.[刘长江, 郝芳. (2011). 不对称社会困境中社会价值取向对合作的影响. 心理学报, 43, 432-441.]

Liu, C. J., Li, Y. M., & Li, S. (2007). Advance in research on social dilemmas:Evidence from experimental social psychology. Advances in Psychological Science, 15, 379-384.[刘长江, 李岩梅, 李纾. (2007). 实验社会心理学中的社会困境. 心理科学进展, 15, 379-384.]

Liu, G. F., & Xin, Z. Q. (2014). The effects of punishment impacting on social trust and cooperation:Controversy and interpretation. Journal of Shanghai Normal University (Philosophy & Social Sciences Edition), 43, 146-152.[刘国芳, 辛自强. (2014). 惩罚对信任与合作的影响:争论与解释. 上海师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 43, 146-152.]

Liu, X., Ma, J. H., & Zhu, Y. (2010). The influence of sanction system on cooperation in public good games from attributional perspective. Chinese Journal of Applied Psychology, 16, 332-340.[刘谞, 马剑虹, 朱玥. (2010). 从归因视角探讨公共物品两难中惩罚系统对合作的影响. 应用心理学, 16, 332-340.]

Maki, J. E., Hoffman, D. M., & Berk, R. A. (1978). A time series analysis of the impact of a water conservation campaign. Evaluation Review, 2, 107-118.

Masclet, D., Noussair, C., Tucker, S., & Villeval, M. C. (2003). Monetary and nonmonetary punishment in the voluntary contributions mechanism. American Economic Review, 93, 366-380.

Masten, C. L., Eisenberger, N. I., Borofsky, L. A., Pfeifer, J. H., McNealy, K., Mazziotta, J. C., & Dapretto, M. (2009). Neural correlates of social exclusion during adolescence:Understanding the distress of peer rejection. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 4(2), 143-157.

McCusker, C., & Carnevale, P. J. (1995). Framing in resource dilemmas:Loss aversion and the moderating effects of sanctions. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 61, 190-201.

Mcwhirter, B. T., Besett-Alesch, T. M., Horibata, J., & Gat, I. (2002). Loneliness in high risk adolescents:The role of coping, self-esteem, and empathy. Journal of Youth Studies, 5, 69-84.

Messick, D. M., (1999). Alternative logics for decision making in social settings. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 39, 11-28.

Mulder, L. B., van Dijk, E., De Cremer, D., & Wilke, H. A. M. (2006). Undermining trust and cooperation:The paradox of sanctioning systems in social dilemmas. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 42, 147-162.

Mulder, L. B., Verboon, P., & De Cremer, D. (2009). Sanctions and moral judgments:The moderating effect of sanction severity and trust in authorities. European Journal of Social Psychology, 39, 255-269.

Murphy, R. O., Ackermann, K. A., & Handgraaf, M. (2011). Measuring social value orientation. Judgment and Decision Making, 6, 771-781.

Nezlek, J. B. (2002). Day-to-day relationships between self-awareness, daily events, and anxiety. Journal of Personality, 70, 249-276.

Pillutla, M. M., & Chen, X. P. (1999). Social norms and cooperation in social dilemmas:The effects of context and feedback. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 78, 81-103.

Pressman, S. D., & Cohen, S. (2005). Does positive affect influence health? Psychological Bulletin, 131, 925-971.

Rand, D. G., Dreber, A., Ellingsen, T., Fudenberg, D., & Nowak, M. A. (2009). Positive interactions promote public cooperation. Science, 325, 1272-1275.

Simpson, B., & van Vugt, M. (2009). Sex differences in cooperation and prosocial behavior. In S. R. Thye & E. J. Lawler (Eds.), Altruism and prosocial behavior in groups, Volume 26 (pp. 81-103). Wagon Lane, UK:Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

Stouten, J., de Cremer, D., & van Dijk, E. (2005). All is well that ends well, at least for proselfs:Emotional reactions to equality violation as a function of social value orientation. European Journal of Social Psychology, 35, 767-783.

Sun, X. Y., Chen, J., Li, H., & Li, X. L. (2009). The impact of cooperation index and the description of payoff matrix on cooperation of the prisoner's dilemma of children. Psychological Development and Education, 25(1), 27-33.[孙昕怡, 陈璟, 李红, 李秀丽. (2009). 合作指数与描述方式对儿童囚徒困境博弈中合作行为的影响. 心理发展与教育, 25(1), 27-33.]

Sutter, M., & Kocher, M. G. (2007). Trust and trustworthiness across different age groups. Games and Economic Behavior, 59, 364-382.

Tenbrunsel, A. E., & Messick, D. M. (1999). Sanctioning systems, decision frames, and cooperation. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44, 684-707.

Utz, S., Ouwerkerk, J. W., & van Lange, P. A. M. (2004). What is smart in a social dilemma? Differential effects of priming competence on cooperation. European Journal of Social Psychology, 34, 317-332.

van den Bos, W., van Dijk, E., Westenberg, M., Rombouts, S. A. R. B., & Crone, E. A. (2011). Changing brains, changing perspectives:The neurocognitive development of reciprocity. Psychological Science, 22, 60-70.

van den Bos, W., Westenberg, M., van Dijk, E., & Crone, E. A. (2010). Development of trust and reciprocity in adolescence. Cognitive Development, 25, 90-102.

van Lange, P. A. M. (2000). Beyond self-interest:A set of propositions relevant to interpersonal orientations. European Review of Social Psychology, 11, 297-331.

van Lange, P. A. M., De Bruin, E. M. N., Otten, W., & Joireman, J. A. (1997). Development of prosocial, individualistic, and competitive orientations:Theory and preliminary evidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 733-764.

van Lange, P. A. M., & Kuhlman, D. M. (1994). Social value orientations and impressions of partner's honesty and intelligence:A test of the might versus morality effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67, 126-141.

van Vugt, M., van Lange, P. A. M., & Meertens, R. M. (1996). Commuting by car or public transportation? A social dilemma analysis of travel mode judgements. European Journal of Social Psychology, 26, 373-395.

Wang, P., & Chen, L. (2011). The effects of sanction and social value orientation on trust and cooperation in public goods dilemmas. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 43, 52-64.[王沛, 陈莉. (2011). 惩罚和社会价值取向对公共物品两难中人际信任与合作行为的影响. 心理学报, 43, 52-64.]

Wedekind, C., & Milinski, M. (2000). Cooperation through image scoring in humans. Science, 288, 850-852.

Weber, J. M., Kopelman, S., & Messick, D. M. (2004). A conceptual review of decision making in social dilemmas:Applying a logic of appropriateness. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 8, 281-307.

Wei, Q. (2009). Some social mechanisms of improving the ability of punishment and maintenance of cooperation in human groups. Economic Research Journal, (10), 133-143, 160.[韦倩. (2009). 增强惩罚能力的若干社会机制与群体合作秩序的维持. 经济研究, (10), 133-143, 160.]

Wu, J. H. (2012). Effects of immediate emotion and decision frame on behavioral decision making of individuals with different social value orientations (Unpublished master's thesis). Beijing Normal University.[伍俊辉. (2012). 即时情绪与决策框架对不同社会价值取向者行为决策的影响 (硕士学位论文). 北京师范大学.]

Xin, Z. Q., Sun, H. Y., Liu, B. Y., & Chi, L. P. (2003). The impact of adolescent's social behaviors on their peer relations. Psychological Development and Education, 19(4), 12-16.[辛自强, 孙汉银, 刘丙元, 池丽萍. (2003). 青少年社会行为对同伴关系的影响. 心理发展与教育, 19(4), 12-16.]

Yan, J., & Wang, Z. M. (2000). The effects of values orientation on group cooperation in social dilemmas. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 32, 332-336.[严进, 王重鸣. (2000). 两难对策中价值取向对群体合作行为的影响. 心理学报, 32, 332-336.]

Yan, L. S., Yan, Z. X., Ding, D. Q., Zou, X., & Fan, W. (2014). The temporal features of physical cleaning processing after moral disgust priming:Evidence of ERPs. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology, 22, 32-37.[燕良轼, 颜志雄, 丁道群, 邹霞, 范伟. (2014). 道德厌恶启动后身体清洁词加工的时间特征:来自ERPs的证据. 中国临床心理学杂志, 22, 32-37.]

Zeng, M. X. (2012). The empirical study of relationship between adolescents' self-concept and integrity behavior (Unpublished master's thesis). Guangzhou University.[曾敏霞. (2012). 青少年道德自我概念与诚信行为关系的实证研究 (硕士学位论文). 广州大学.]

Zhang, Z., Zhang, F., Huang, L., Yuan, B., & Wang, Y. W. (2014). Theories and measurement methods of social value orientation related to decision making. Advances in Psychological Science, 22, 48-56.[张振, 张帆, 黄亮, 袁博, 王益文. (2014). 决策中社会价值取向的理论与测评方法. 心理科学进展, 22, 48-56.]

Zhu, Y. (2008). The effects of sanctioning systems on cooperation and trust in public goods dilemma (Unpublished master's thesis). Zhejiang University, Hangzhou.[朱玥. (2008). 公共物品两难情境中奖惩系统对合作行为以及信任的影响研究 (硕士学位论文). 浙江大学, 杭州.]